A comparison of the Spaniel breeds (Gundog Group), their history,
development & roles
(By Chris Pritchard)
Introduction
The earliest mention of the dogs we have come to regard as Spaniels can be
found in English literature and is contained in the celebrated "Master of Game,"
an elaborate treatise on hunting. This was the work of Edward Plantagenet,
second Duke of York, and Master of Game to his uncle, Henry IV., to whom the
work is dedicated. The "Master of Game," was written between the years 1406 and
1413, and although none of the manuscripts, of which some sixteen are in
existence, is dated, this date can be fairly accurately fixed, as the author was
appointed Master of Game in the early 1400's and was killed at Agincourt on 25th
October 1415.
The Duke's chapter on Spaniels, however, is mainly a translation from the
equally celebrated "Livre de Chasse," of Gaston Comte de Foix, generally known
as Gaston Phoebus, which was written in 1387, so that we may safely assume that
Spaniels were well known, and habitually used as aids to the chase both in
France and England, as early as the middle of the fourteenth century.
The comparatively “modern” Spaniels were developed in the late 1700's and the
early 1800's from couching dogs of Medieval Europe and possibly hounds.
In the late 17th century the flintlock gun was introduced into Britain,
making it possible for sportsmen to engage in 'flying shooting' as opposed to
netting - and this is what prompted the development of the Spaniel and various
other Gundog breeds.
Although popular wisdom attributes the source of the spaniel to Spain,
British canine historian Colonel David Hancock traced the word “spaniel” to the
French verb Espanir, “to crouch or flatten,” and even further back to the Latin
Explanere and the Italian Spianare, also “to flatten or flatten out.” He also
found the old Italian verb Spaniare, meaning “to get out of a trap or net.”
Hancock believed that the dogs originated with the Romans and were called
spaniels to describe a hunting style of crouching and springing to flush game
into the hunters nets or for the falcons or sight hounds to pursue.
The Spaniel family is without any doubt one of the most important of the many
groups which are included in the canine race, not only on account of its
undoubted antiquity, and, compared with other families, its well authenticated
lineage, but also because of its many branches and subdivisions, ranging in size
from the majestic and massive Clumbers to the diminutive toys.
Moreover, the different varieties of Setters undoubtedly derive their origin
from the same parent stock, since we find them described by the earlier sporting
writers as "setting" or "crouching" Spaniels, in contradistinction to the
"finding" or "springing" Spaniel, who flushed the game he found without setting
or pointing it. As time went on, the setting variety was, no doubt, bred larger
and longer in the leg, with a view to increased pace; but the Spaniel-like head
and coat still remain to prove the near connection between the two breeds.
All the different varieties of Spaniels, both sporting and toy, have, with
the exception of the Clumber and the Irish Water Spaniel (who is not, despite
his name, a true Spaniel at all), a common origin, though at a very early date
we find them divided into two groups viz., Land and Water Spaniels, and these
two were kept distinct, and bred to develop those points which were most
essential for their different spheres of work.
The Cocker Spaniel
One of the breeders of Cockers whose dogs appear in the first stud book of
1874 is Mr W Boulton of Accrington in Lancashire. He also bred some of the
most influential Field Spaniels of the time, all bred from the same stock. These
first two Cockers were named Regent and Regal (litter brothers). Mr W Twists
Dash and Mr S Ridleys Bob also featured at the time.
It is not easy to find authentic pedigrees but Mr. C. A. Phillips can trace
his own strain back to 1860 and was able to publish the pedigree of Rivington
Dora for 18 generations!
In 1870 Mr Richard Lloyd founded a kennel of spaniels. His stock encompassed
both Field and Cockers. He based his lines on Mr. Bolton's, Mr Bowers and the
Rev. Shields lines and proceeded along quite different lines to his contemporary
Mr Farrow. Mr Lloyd's first entries in the stud book were with Beauty and
Countess.
Mr Lloyd subsequently went back to the Field and Sussex lines to secure an
important brood bitch called Frivolity from Dr Spurgin. Upon the death of
Richard Lloyd his son Hubert Summers Lloyd took over the kennel and with his
keen eye for a dog took the kennel forward in a different manner to his father.
Currently the Of Ware line is in the stewardship of Jennifer Lloyd Carey who is
the daughter of H S Lloyd.
It was in 1880 that the most famous of all the "pillars" of the Cocker stud,
Mr. James Farrow's Obo (born 14/06/1879), made his first bow to the public, he
and his litter sister Sally having been born the year before. He won the highest
honours that the show bench can give, and the importance of his service to the
breed both in his owner's kennel and outside it, can scarcely be over-estimated.
Nearly all of the best blacks, and many of the best coloured Cockers, are
descended from him. At this period the type mostly favoured was that of a dog
rather longer in the body and lower on the leg than it is at present, but the
Obo family marked a progressive step, and very rightly kept on winning under all
the best judges for many years, their owner being far too good a judge himself
ever to exhibit anything but first-class specimens.
The famous Obo strain of the latter may be said to have exercised more
influence than any other on the black variety both in this country and in the
United States.
Meanwhile, although the blacks were far the most fashionable, among them was
Mr. C. A. Phillips, whose two bitches from Mr. James Freme, of Wepre Hall,
Flintshire, succeeded in breeding from one of them, whom he named Rivington
Sloe, the celebrated dog Rivington Signal, who, mated with Rivington Blossom,
produced Rivington Bloom, who was in turn the dam of Rivington Redcoat. These
dogs proved almost, if not quite, as valuable to the coloured variety as Obo did
to the blacks, and formed the foundation of Mr. J. M. Porter's celebrated
Braeside strain which afterwards became so famous. Mr Porter's line started in
the mid 1880's. Braeside Bustle was whelped in July 1894 and put coloured
Cockers on the map.
Braeside Bustle (blue roan) was line bred to Mr Lloyd's Frivolity and his
sire was Mr Lloyd's Viceroy (S: Toots x D: Coquette) who incidentally were both
black!
These early Cocker spaniels formed the foundation of the breed as we know it
today and lie behind all the current day dogs. Cocker Spaniel’s were developed
to locate the whereabouts of the live quarry by scent and then to flush the
quarry out of the hiding places by going into and under bushes and brambles to
disturb the quarry and bring it out into the open. open.
The Cocker Spaniel Club was founded in 1902.
The development of the distinct breeds of Spaniel
Unlike the present day, the early spaniels originated from litters that had
the same parents. These parents were spaniel like in appearance although their
pedigrees were often unknown in many instances. Good record keeping wasn't
maintained and the breeders tended to name their dogs with simple names.
Therefore it was common to find that “Mary” had whelped a litter to “Bob”. The
unanswered question is who was Mary or Bob and which Mary and Bob were they!
Once the pups were born and as they developed and matured they were then
classified according to size. By 1800, three general classifications were
established: Cockers, used for flushing woodcock weighed up to 25 lbs. the
larger dogs, 17-18 inches tall and weighing 35 to 45 lbs. were Field or English
spaniels. English spaniels included Springer's, Field's, Sussex, and the Clumber
spaniel.
Miniature, or toy, spaniels fancied by King Charles and the Duke Norfolk were
called "Comforters" and we know these spaniels as Toy spaniels today. At this
time liver and black were the primary colours. It is not until some time later
that the breeds were separated and started being breed being from homozygous
parents. The Field Spaniels retained the solid colours (liver and black)
although parti-coloured specimens did occur, however these were usually culled.
The Sussex spaniel remained liver, the Welsh and Springer spaniels were liver
and white and latterly black and white or liver and white for the English
Springer and red and white for the Welsh Springer. The Cocker Spaniels
diversified from liver and black to red, black and tan in the solid colours and
a variety of parti-colours.
The Sussex Spaniel
The Sussex is one of the oldest of the distinct breeds of Land Spaniels now
existing in the British Isles, and probably also the purest in point of
descent, since it has for many years past been confined to a comparatively
small number of kennels, the owners of which have always been at
considerable pains to keep their strains free from any mixture of foreign
blood.
The modern race of Sussex Spaniels, as we know it, owes its origin in the
main to the large kennels kept by Mr. Fuller at Rosehill Park, Brightling, near
Hastings. Sussex spaniels were originally bred as gundogs to work the thick
heavy clay soil and dense gorse bushes of Sussex and West Kent in England (hence
their name!).
This gentleman, who died in 1847, is said to have kept his strain for fifty
years or more, and to have shot over them almost daily during the season. Upon
his death they were dispersed by auction, and none of them can be traced with
any accuracy except a dog and a bitch which were given at the time to Relf, the
head keeper. Relf survived Mr Fuller for forty years, and kept up his interest
in the breed to the last. He used to say that the golden tinge peculiar to the
Rosehill breed came from a bitch which had been mated with a dog belonging to
Dr. Watts, of Battle, and that every now and then what he termed a "sandy" pup
would turn up in her litters.
Several enthusiasts began to revive the breed in or around 1870. Mr. Saxby
and Mr. Marchant are said to have had the same strain as that at Rosehill, and
certainly one of the most famous sires who is to be found in most Sussex
pedigrees was Buckingham, by Marchant's Rover out of Saxby's Fan.
It was from the union of Buckingham, who was claimed to be pure Rosehill with
Bebb's daughter Peggie that the great Bachelor resulted, a dog whose name is to
be found in almost every latter-day pedigree, though Mr. Campbell Newington's
strain, to which has descended the historic prefix "Rosehill".
Around 1879 Mr. T. Jacobs, of Newton Abbot, took up this breed with great
success, owning, amongst other good specimens, Russett, Dolly, Brunette, and
Bachelor III., the latter a dog whose services at the stud cannot be estimated
too highly. When this kennel was broken up in 1891, the best of the Sussex
Spaniels were acquired by Mr. Woolland, and from that date this gentleman's
kennel carried all before it until it in turn was broken up and dispersed in
1905. So successful was Mr. Woolland that one may almost say that he beat all
other competitors off the field, though one of them, Mr. Campbell Newington,
stuck most gallantly to him all through.
Mr. Campbell Newington had been breeding Sussex Spaniels for over a quarter
of a century with an enthusiasm and tenacity worthy of the warmest admiration,
and his strain is probably the purest, and more full of the original blood than
any other. His kennel has always maintained a very high standard of excellence,
and many famous show specimens have come from it, notably Rosehill Ruler II. (a
splendid Sussex, scarcely inferior to Bridford Giddie), Romulus, Roein, Rita,
Rush, Rock, Rag, and Ranji, and many others of almost equal merit.
Colonel Claude Cane's kennel of Sussex, started from a "Woolland-bred"
foundations, the best he has shown being Jonathan Swift, Celbridge Eldorado, and
Celbridge Chrysolite.
By the time of the Second World War there were few Sussex being bred from and
it is thought that after the war only 5 Sussex Spaniels remained.
Fortunately the breed has had dedicated followers and in particular Miss
Schofield who became Mrs Freer (Fourclovers), kept the breed going throughout
the War Years. After that it was a long haul to get the numbers up again. Mrs
Freer devoted her time and energy over a period of 60 years to breeding Sussex
Spaniels.
The Sussex Spaniel Association was formed in 1924. The breed has always had a
good character for work, and most of the older writers who mention them speak of
Sussex Spaniels in very eulogistic terms. They are rather slow workers, but
thoroughly conscientious and painstaking, and are not afraid of any amount of
thick covert, through which they will force their way, and seldom leave anything
behind them. The Sussex is an expert in tracking smells, once prey is found he
barks to alert his master.
A well-bred Sussex Spaniel is a very handsome dog. Indeed, his beautiful
colour alone is enough to make his appearance an attractive one, even if he
appears unsymmetrical and ungainly in his proportions.
This colour, known as golden liver, is peculiar to the breed, and is the
great touchstone and hall-mark of purity of blood. No other dog has exactly the
same shade of coat, which the word "liver" hardly describes exactly, as it is
totally different from the ordinary liver colour of a Pointer, or even a liver
Field Spaniel. It is rather a golden chestnut with a regular metallic sheen as
of burnished metal, showing more especially on the head and face and everywhere
where the hair is short. This is very apparent when a dog gets his new coat.
The Clumber Spaniel

The Clumber was developed for use as a “beater” to flush wild game,
Clumber’s are able to leave no cover unexplored as they push their way into
the thickest cover and drive the game out from within for the guns.
Tradition has it that the first Clumber Spaniel type of dog arrived at
Clumber Park in Nottinghamshire from the kennels of the French aristocrat, the
Duc de Noailles, at around the time of the French revolution (years 1789-1815).
However no trace of their origin can be found in France and for the present
day at least the Clumber is accepted as a purely English product. It has been
suggested that the Duke of Newcastle, finding that the Spaniels that had been
presented to him were too fast, reduced their pace by crossing them with a
heavier breed. What the cross or crosses were will never be known, but the
Clumber's general type, his massive frame, powerful limbs, white coat with lemon
markings, and his solemn and majestic aspect and demeanour suggest the St.
Bernard. There is also a theory that they owe their origin to a cross of Baron
Cuvier's Alpine Spaniel, a dog indirectly related to the St. Bernard.
It is without doubt that the Clumber we know today was developed by the
gamekeepers to his Grace. The Mansell family served and supplied gamekeepers to
the Duke and his descendants for at least five generations and for this time
(1760s to 1850s) of one hundred and ten years essentially had control of the
white spaniel and its breeding.
From Clumber Park specimens found their way to most of the other great houses
in the neighbourhood, notably to Althorp Park, Welbeck Abbey, Birdsall House,
Thoresby Hall, and Osberton Hall. culminating with King Edward VII. He enjoyed
using his Clumbers at Sandringham where he bred many working and show champions,
the best remembered of these being Sandringham Sparkle.
It is from Osberton Hall kennels owned by owned by Mr. Foljambe, that most of
the progenitors of the Clumbers which have earned notoriety derived their
origin.
Nearly all the most famous show winners of early days were descended from Mr.
Foljambe's dogs, and his Beau may perhaps be considered one of the most
important "pillars of the stud," as he was the sire of Nabob, a great
prize-winner, and considered one of the best of his day, who belonged at various
times during his career to such famous showmen as Messrs. Phineas Bullock, Mr.
Fletcher, Mr. Rawdon Lee, and Mr. G. Oliver.
The Clumber Spaniel was recognised officially in 1879.
The Welsh Springer Spaniel
Welsh Springer’s are reputed to be a cross between the English Springer and
probably a Clumber in order to account for the red or orange markings and
the vine-leaf-shaped ears however there is some evidence that the Brittany
Spaniel featured somewhere along the lines as the Welsh Springer Spaniel’s
head is similar to the Brittany.
The breed appears to have originated in Wales and was first recognised by The
Kennel Club in 1902. Prior to this recognition they were known as Welsh Cockers.
This type of dog was bred for hunting rabbits, birds and other game in the
undergrowth and getting them to run or fly, originally for the falcon but
nowadays, for the gun.
It is unknown exactly how old the breed is. However, a painting by Van Dyck
in 1680 depicts a dog which looks like very much like a Welsh Springer Spaniel,
and it is obviously a very ancient and distinct breed of pure origin. They were
originally bred for, and indeed still used for, flushing game for the hunter to
despatch.
Rover of Gerwyn, born in 1901 was the first champion of the breed. However,
it was after the wars that breeding began in a larger scale.
The Welsh Spaniel Club was established in 1923.
The English Springer Spaniel
By the year 1812 a pure strain of English Springer’s was being developed.
The Boughey family of Aqualate in Shropshire bred ‘Mop 1’.
He is the first recorded English Springer and appeared rather “Clumberish”
with a coat which was inclined to be curly, however he was of the desired
Springer type.
English Springer Spaniels were originally known as Norfolk Spaniels, they
subsequently gained the title of English Springer Spaniels because of their
usefulness in "springing" game for the gun. There was not much breeding in the
Norfolk area; still the breed was named after Duke of Norfolk who, in fact,
lived in Sussex! The name was officially changed into Springer Spaniel in 1902.
It was already then that the two varieties, English and Welsh Springer’s were
recognised.
English Springer Spaniels were liver and white or black and white and were
17-18 inches tall at the shoulder.
In 1899, a newly formed Sporting Spaniel Society held working trials on the
estate of its president, William Arkwright of Sutton, Scarsdale.
The first Springer Field Champion in the world was Rivington Sam (who’s
mother was registered as a Cocker spaniel and features heavily in the early
Cocker pedigrees), lies behind many of the present-day Springer's. It was
generally acknowledged that Sam was a first cross between a Cocker and an
English Setter and over the years, outcross blood of breeds such as the Clumber
Spaniel, the Irish Setter, and the Field Spaniel was introduced. This had some
advantages, such as improving heads, but, fortunately, the Springer emerged as
an entirely distinctive breed.
As with all the early Spaniels, dogs were much of a mixed bag, and when
English and Welsh Springer’s were given recognition as separate breeds in 1902,
recognition was purely on the basis of appearance. Many dogs were registered
with doubtful pedigrees and some with no pedigree at all. As a general rule, if
the dog was red-and-white, it was registered as a Welsh Springer, and if it was
liver-and-white, it was classed as an English Springer, although a number of
other physical characteristics would also have separated the breeds.
The principal breeders and owners have so far been Mr. W. Arkwright (as
mentioned above), Mr. Harry Jones, Sir Hugo FitzHerbert (also mentioned above),
Mr. C. Bethune Eversfield, and Mr. Winton Smith.
In 1903 the Kennel Club offered a class especially for English Springers at
their show, and in 1906 the liver-and-white dog Beechgrove Will was made the
first Champion in the breed, and Fansom became the first Champion bitch.
Springer Spaniel’s were developed to locate the whereabouts of the live
quarry by scent and then to flush the quarry out of the hiding places by
springing into and over the bushes and brambles to disturb the quarry and bring
it out into the open.
The English Springer Spaniel Club was founded in 1921.
The Field Spaniel
In common with all the Spaniels the Cocker Spaniel and the Field Spaniel
was the same breed only separated by weight. The Cocker Spaniel was shown
under 25 pounds and the Field Spaniel was shown over 25 pounds.
The breed then took a different path, which nearly led to its destruction.
The breed became a short-legged, heavy-boned dog, only 12 inches high and
weighing as much as 40 pounds. In 1948, the Field Spaniel Society was reformed
in Britain and breeders started eliminating the exaggerations in the breed.
The modern Field Spaniel may be divided into two classes. Indeed, we may
almost say at this stage of canine history, two breeds, as for several years
past there has not been very much intermingling of blood between the Blacks and
those known by the awkward designation of "Any Other Variety," though, of
course, all came originally from the same parent stock.
It is clear that a dog similar to the Field Spaniel has been around for a
long time. C. DE Arcussia in his book on Falconry written in 1598 speaks of them
and of their being used in connection with the sport of hawking.
The first strain of blacks of which we know more about belonged to Mr. F.
Burdett, and was obtained from a Mr. Footman, of Lutterworth, Leicestershire,
who was supposed to have owned them for some time. Mr. Burdett's Bob and Frank
may be found at the head of very many of the best pedigrees including Cocker
Spaniel pedigrees which further goes to illustrate the intermingling of Field
and Cocker Spaniels at the outset.
Upon the death of Mr Burdett most of his Spaniels became the property of Mr.
Jones, of Oscott, and Mr. Phineas Bullock, of Bilston, the latter of whom was
most extraordinarily successful, and owned a kennel of Field Spaniels which was
practically unbeatable between the dates of the first Birmingham Show in 1861
and the publication of the first volume of the Kennel Club's Stud Book in 1874,
many, if not most, of the dogs which won for other owners having been bred by
him. His Nellie and Bob, who won the chief prizes year after year at all the
leading shows, were probably the two best specimens of their day.
Another most successful breeder was Mr. W. W. Boulton, of Beverley, whose
kennel produced many celebrated dogs, including Beverlac, said to be the largest
Field Spaniel ever exhibited, and Rolf, whose union with Belle produced four
bitches who were destined, when mated with Nigger, a dog of Mr. Bullock's
breeding, to form the foundation of the equally if not more famous kennel
belonging to Mr. T. Jacobs, of Newton Abbot.
It was Mr. Jacobs who, by judiciously mating his Sussex sires Bachelor and
Bachelor III., and others with these black-bred bitches, established the strain
which in his hands and in those of his successors, Captain S. M. Thomas and Mr.
Moses Woolland, carried all before it for many years, and is still easily at the
top of the tree, being the most sought for and highly prized of all on account
of its "quality."
The original Field Spaniels were black or liver with black being the dominant
colour (as with many of the original Spaniels). The points of both black and
coloured Field Spaniels are identical, bar colour, and here it must be said that
black and tan, liver and tan, and liver are not considered true variety colours,
though of course they have to compete in those classes.
Some of the earliest breeders of the Field Spaniel are Mr. F. E. Schofield,
Dr. J. H. Spurgin, and Mr. J. W. Robinson. In the early days of breeding blacks,
when the bitches were mated either with Sussex or liver and white Springer’s or
Norfolk Spaniels, many parti-coloured puppies resulted however these were
usually destroyed by the breeders.
The Field Spaniel is used for his ability to flush and retrieve birds from
dense undergrowth.
The Field Spaniel Society was founded in 1923.
The American Cocker Spaniel
The first Cocker in America is said to have arrived with the Pilgrim Fathers
on the Mayflower in 1620. Settlers in subsequent centuries brought more with
them to help explore and exploit the country's wildernesses.
American Cockers were developed from the English Cocker in the 19th century,
to retrieve quail and woodcock. The English and American Cocker Spaniel had
identical histories up until around the 1930's. They were considered one breed
of spaniel.
Originally they were divided from the English Cocker solely on the basis of
size, but over the years they were bred for specific traits and the differences
grew greater. By the 1940s the American Cocker differed so much in type from the
English Cocker that it became impossible to judge them together and in 1945 the
two breeds were separated and each officially recognised with their own
standards.
As with the other Spaniel breeds, American and English Cocker Spaniels were
classified by size. Thus several different types of spaniels could come from the
same litter. Cockers and toys were the smaller types, and, as the toy spaniels
were bred as ladies' companions and Cockers were kept for hunting, were further
divided into two groups. Later, spaniels were divided according to their method
of hunting: Crouching or setting spaniels, and springing or finding spaniels.
The Cockers were crouchers, and they were used particularly to hunt woodcock a
game bird these spaniels flushed particularly well. The name "Cocker" comes from
the woodcock.
Conclusions
It can be seen from the histories of the separate Spaniel breeds that our
current day dogs all shared the same foundations. I don’t think that we will
ever be sure who the first Spaniel was or where he came from but through the
determination and foresight of the early day enthusiasts we have derived the
subdivisions of the breed that we hold so dear today.
The breeds may have diversified in many ways but they all share the same
wonderful characteristics. They are loyal and devoted dogs who have great
abilities in the field. Their stamina is outstanding and they will work happily
all day, often in the harshest of weather or environment.
Their versatility is unique, they have the ability to find prey in the most
adverse of surroundings, they will flush, spring or drive their pray into the
open and once shot and dispatched by the Guns’ the majority of them will move
heaven and high water to retrieve the fallen birds. These are gently and
carefully returned to their master and arrive undamaged due to the softness of
their mouths. Their temperaments are sound; they have happy natures and are a
joy to behold.
Their wonderful predisposition is not only of benefit in a working sphere but
also as companions. Their biddable natures make them delightful pets that
provide a great deal of joy to their owners.
Bibliography:
- The Heritage of the Dog by David Hancock
- The Cynographia Britannica by Sydenham Edwards
- Dogs and All About Them by Robert Leighton
- Pet Owner's Guide To The English Springer Spaniel by Don Miller
- The White Spaniel by David Hancock
- A History of the Cocker Spaniel by Peggy Grayson
- The Clumber Spaniel by Peggy Grayson
- The Sussex Spaniel by Peggy Grayson